Businesses periodically clean house and destroy documents, delete e-mail, and clear hard drives. But you may ask, “When is it safe to destroy business documents?” The answer is: It is permissible to shred documents and delete computer files, unless when the destruction took place you had a duty to preserve that property.
The duty to preserve can arise from a contractual obligation or a regulatory requirement, as well as when property is or could be evidence in a current, pending, or reasonably foreseeable lawsuit. Failure to preserve documents in this latter category may result in ‘spoliation’ – the destruction of, or failure to preserve, evidence. The spoliation standard, however, is unsettled.
Some courts do not consider destruction of potential evidence before a lawsuit is filed as spoliation, while others find a duty to preserve arises when a party should reasonably know that litigation is imminent. Some courts presume document destruction under a company policy is innocent, while others question whether a duty to preserve was triggered regardless of such a policy.
Of course, you should never destroy any document – whether a paper or electronic record – with the intent of preventing its discovery by a potential litigant. If you are concerned that a document could expose a party to liability, it is too late. Destroying a document after a duty to preserve arises may result in severe court-imposed sanctions, imposition of a ‘spoliation inference’, or the court excluding evidence (which may tip the scales in favor of the injured party). For example, the court may instruct a jury to assume a destroyed document would have proven that which your adversary claims.
It is good practice for a business to adopted records retention policies that demonstrate regular document destruction. Reasonable routine document destruction policies would lend support to the position that the destruction was not an attempt to purge files of incriminating documents. Some key points to keep in mind when creating and maintaining a records retention policy include:
If you do not have a record retention policy and you destroy records that later on become relevant to litigation, you may find it hard to justify your action. Have a records retention policy and then, like with any policy, follow it – except when there is a document preservation notice or reason to believe litigation on a subject is likely. If you are interested in developing a document retention policy, feel free to call for a consultation.
This week the Federal Trade Commission upended the world of employment law by passing a…
Is withholding tips illegal in Virginia? A large portion of Virginia employees who wait tables,…
Virginia minimum wage laws are created to protect employees from exploitation and unduly low pay.…
Is my spouse a narcissist? It can be a difficult question to answer. When does…
Do you have questions about your employer? There are many laws and regulations that help…
When it comes to family law, people often have many different questions. Family law is…